Dominick's Italian Restaurant

The spot, the food, and the reaction

Dominick's in Totowa serves up an old-school square pie that's truly something special. It's got a rich sauce that's super confident, and a dusting of pecorino cheese that you can smell before you even take a bite. This place has a real cult following because they just refuse to change anything, and people love them for it.

It's not just that people like Dominick's; they defend it with all their might! That's the sign of truly great pizza. It's not about a perfect score, but about having a loyal group ready to go to bat for their favorite square slice.

With cult square in the mix, this Oxnard, CA stop gives hungry people a pretty tasty reason to show up. cult square also gets some well-earned attention, because one good bite should never have to carry the whole meal alone. Between cult square and cult square, the order has enough personality to make an ordinary food run feel like a small treat.