131 Essex St, New York, NY 10002 · Hamburger Restaurant
Gotham Burger Social Club in New York City is definitely making waves, especially with their smash burgers. The "Bon Appétit" video highlights this, calling it "one of New York City's most talked-about smash burger restaurants. It seems like the creator was really impressed by the buzz around the place and its reputation for those smash burgers.
While they also mention other tasty-sounding items like Oklahoma-style onion burgers, chopped cheese tacos, and fried pickles, the main takeaway from the video's quote is how popular Gotham Burger Social Club is, particularly for its smash burgers. It's a spot that's clearly on people's radar in the city. That is the limit of what the clips establish: they capture what Bon Appétit highlighted, not a review of every dish on the menu.
Taken together, the named items and the creators’ own reactions make the recommendation easy to understand without adding claims the videos never made.
one of New York City's most talked-about smash burger restaurants — our read of Bon Appétit’s verdict
Oklahoma-style onion burgerschopped cheese tacosfried picklessmash burgers
More viral food spots in New York →