What to order, what food creators said, and the verified links you need to plan a visit in New York, NY.
174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010 · American Restaurant
Hours, prices, availability, and service details can change. Confirm them with the restaurant before visiting.
S&P Lunch is an old-school lunch counter at 174 Fifth Avenue, near the Flatiron Building. A diner has been at this spot since 1928. NYT Cooking featured it in its Sandwich City series.
The video focused on the tuna melt and the egg creams. The host loved the place. The video praised both the food and the warm, friendly staff.
The menu lists the tuna melt as tuna salad and American cheese on griddled rye. Egg creams come in chocolate, vanilla, or coffee. The menu also has matzo ball soup and a patty melt.
The counter seats fill up fast, even in the morning. It is open from 8am on weekdays and 9am on weekends. Check the menu on the website before you go.
Our score shows how the video reacted, not a star rating. We have not eaten here.
The evidence record for S&P Lunch contains 2 credited source videos, 727 thousand combined views, and a 97/100 Creator Score. The named orders in that record are egg creams, tuna melt, Bloody Mary, S&P regular sandwich. For S&P Lunch, the score describes the source creator's food reaction; it is not a customer-star average, inspection grade, or firsthand TrendBites review.
Iconic old-school lunch counter with classic sandwiches. — our read of NYT Cooking’s verdict
One of my favorite places I've been in recent memory. So cool. — our read of Ben Lippett’s verdict
egg creamstuna meltBloody MaryS&P regular sandwichlatkesmatzo ball souppatty meltspicy sweet cherry peppersthick-cut smoked pastrami
Your response is not connected to personal information. We use it only to improve TrendBites.